Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Taliban-Pakistan truce: Why India should worry

By M H Ahssan

India intelligence agencies are worried about the peace deal between the Taliban and the Pakistani Government in the Swat Valley.

The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) believes that it needs to convince the West that a Talibanised Pakistan with nuclear weapons would be a huge threat to the world.

On February 1, almost two weeks before the imposition of the Sharia law and the truce between the Taliban and Pakistani forces came into effect, National Security Advisor MK Narayanan has said that India was concerned about the stability of Pakistan

"As far as India is concerned as much as that we don't allow our neighbour to go under forces which will definitely be much more inimicable to India than the civilian government there," Narayanan had said.

But those words conceal a mountain of worries. India's intelligence establishment has no doubt that a Taliban takeover will inspire and encourage like-minded groups within India.

They will find safe haven and sanctuaries in Pakistan, the intensity and sophistication of terror strikes will increase and communal polarisation will grow.

So how does India measure up to the challenge of a Talibanised Pakistan?

The most obvious would involve beefing up the armed forces, upgrading counter-terror capabilities and tightening internal security.

But pre-emptive strikes of some kind or even armed conflict are seen as a risky alternative for India.

"The option for India would be either to sit back and wait for this Talibanisation to slowly creep towards us or to go to Afghanistan and help fight it," says Former MEA secretary KC Singh.

The thinking in South Block is that India needs to convince the West that a Talibanised Pakistan is a threat to the world.

Pakistan has nuclear weapons, has expertise in chemical and biological warfare and could be dangerously appealing to a Muslim diaspora in the West that has been under pressure since 9/11.

"That is the big danger and is the big threat which causes panic in the capitals of all western countries because they all believe that if there is a dirty bomb or a nuclear bomb exploded by a terrorist, the source would be Pakistan," former R&AW chief Anand Kumar Verma says.

Intelligence experts believe the West knows and understands the danger.

The US missile strikes in Pakistan's tribal territories is a small-scale war that has taken a heavy toll on Taliban capabilities.

Alongside, Indian diplomats say, the US should bring in key Pakistan allies like China and Saudi Arabia to stabilise and bring peace to Pakistan.

But in the event the Taliban are seen to be moving in on Islamabad or there is a danger of Pakistan's nuclear weapons falling into their hands. America's mini war in the tribal territories could escalate into a full-scale war with uncertain consequences.

Sharia imposed, peace returns to Pak's Swat Valley
The beautiful Swat Valley, also known as the Switzerland of Pakistan, is now under the control of Taliban. For the past many years, it has been the scene of fierce battle between the Taliban and Pakistani forces.

Following the imposition of Sharia law and the peace deal, guns have finally fallen silent in the region.

Cheerful voices have replaced the gunfire and laughter has replaced cries but not without a mix of ground realities.

The Pakistan government signed a truce with the Taliban and local hardliners accepting imposition of the Islamic law in an attempt to curb terror in the Swat Valley.

While the world has been sceptical of the deal, residents are rejoicing as children can now go back to schools, vehicles are back on the roads and the markets abuzz with activity.

"We are very happy with the accord between the TSNM and the government," a resident of the region says.

Even as critics have warned of repercussions, the Pakistan Government made it clear that the deal was reached keeping in mind the interests of the people of the Swat valley region.

Now people are seen crowding streets and markets without fear. Mingora witnessed open markets till late evening almost after one and a half year.

Traders, too, are happy with the boom at the local markets...

"Now that the curfew has been lifted our business will definitely do well. We are very happy," says a trader.

People staying in relief camps are now returning back to their homes in the Swat Valley.

Residents are also hoping that peace persists for a long time to come.

But though the truce may have brought temporary peace to the area, with a thriving arms market and lawless society, will peace just be a pause in the long history of violence in this north western region of Pakistan is left for time to tell?

Meanwhile, Chairman of Pakistan National Security Committee Raza Rabbani says he supports the truce in the Swat Valley

"Our ruling elite must come to terms with the truth that what we consider to be our Western values cannot hold grounds all the time. You have to mix values with ground realities and give it a touch which is Pakistani," says Rabbani.

FLOOD OF PEOPLE, TRICKLE OF FUNDS

By Maria Kutty

With remittances from the Gulf dropping and laid-off Indians returning, the slowdown could hit home sooner than expected

For long, it was the Malayali’s Promised Land. The lure of shining cars, neon lights and petro-dollars has had Keralites flocking to Dubai since the mid-1970s. The money they sent back bolstered the state’s economy for over three decades, but the good times seem to be coming to an end, with the economic recession setting in.

An estimated 5.7 million Indian workers abroad sent home $27 billion in 2007 to make India the world's top receiver of migrant remittances, according to a World Bank report. And Kerala accounts for 19.4% or almost a fifth of all remittances by NRIs.

There are about 19 lakh Keralites in the Gulf, and 56% of remittances to the state originate from there. Economists believe that the slowdown in the Gulf countries will have a major impact on the state as it is heavily dependent on NRI remittances for its consumption expenditure.

Remittance figures with the state-level bankers’ committee show a decline in the contribution by non-residents to the total deposits received by commercial banks in Kerala since 2007. While overseas deposits comprised 32% of total bank deposits in Kerala as of September 2007, it has dropped to 27.71% in September 2008. The deposits received by the state’s banks as on September 2007 was Rs 97,113.30 crore, of which non-residents accounted for Rs 31,690 crore. But by September 2008, banks had received Rs 1,13,985 crore, of which just Rs 31,585 crore came from overseas residents.

There may be a fall in Gulf remittances as hundreds of jobs are lost in Dubai on a daily basis. Sudhir Kumar Shetty, general manager of UAE Exchange, Abu Dhabi, says, “We have not seen much of a dip in remittances compared to last year, but with new contracts not being signed and projects postponed, the situation looks bleak. There is going to be no growth in 2009.”

A number of economic activities in the state, notably trade, real estate and construction, were financed by remittances, says a study done by Thiruvananthapuram-based Centre for Development Studies. The report submitted to the state government in December 2008 says the growth in remittances could see a reduced rate during the short and medium terms.

“We never expected the problem in Gulf to be so bad. Though we mentioned that remittances could be one channel through which recession could hit us, we underestimated its effect,” says K J Joseph, who helped conduct the study.

Though there are no official figures for the number of Indians returning home, there are other indicators to show how bad the situation is. Dil Koshy, secretary of Agricultural Products and Processed Food Exporters’ Association (APEXA) says, “Since December 2008, there has been a 40% fall in export of fresh vegetables and other food items to Dubai.” Officials at the air cargo division of Kerala State Industrial Enterprises speak of a 20% fall in imports.

State finance minister T M Thomas Isaac says the worst is yet to come. “The situation is going to worsen in the coming months, particularly after March when the schools have their holidays,” he says.

However, tourism arrivals have not fallen. “Contrary to expectations, tourist arrivals for December 2008 have recorded a one per cent rise over December 2007. It is very reassuring, given that we were expecting a 25% to 30% drop,” says tourism secretary V Venu.

Schools have no space for returning students
Schools in Kerala are being flooded with enquiries for admission from Gulf countries, with thousands of overseas residents returning home after losing jobs. Ever since mega-construction projects in places like Dubai were shelved due to the slowdown, it is believed that thousands of Indians, many from Kerala, have been retrenched. Enquiries by HNN confirmed that many had already landed in Kerala, while a few fortunate ones have got time till March when children complete the school year.

Jomon Joseph from Thrissur was laid off by a construction company in Dubai. His son and daughter are studying in class IX and II. “I’ve been trying for their admission back home as I need to pack up by March, but I haven’t been lucky,” he says.

P Sunder, administrator, Chinmaya Vidyalaya, says they can admit new children only when others leave.

CBSE school rules state that the number of students in a class should not exceed 35. “We should be allowed to accommodate more students. This time, the requirement for new seats is far higher than the expected exit,” says E Ramankutty, Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan’s Kochi Kendra director.

The government could also grant ‘no objection’ certificates to schools awaiting CBSE affiliation. Some schools have approached courts to direct the government to grant NOCs. There are 300 schools awaiting NOCs. Education minister M A Baby told TOI it would be better if parents put their wards in government schools with state syllabus. “We are ready to relax norms to accommodate children. But granting NOC to CBSE schools is a major policy issue that we don’t encourage,” he says.

Malkajgiri Constituency Map

Malkajgiri Constituency Map

EC bans exit, opinion poll till voting comes to a close

By Sudha Raman

The Election Commission on Tuesday banned dissemination of results of opinion and exit polls during the 48-hour period till the polling ends in case of single-phase election. It also banned exit polls till the last lap in the event of multi-phase elections.

The EC’s move comes against the backdrop of the Supreme Court leaving it to the discretion of the commission to decide on laying down guidelines on opinion and exit polls till the government frames regulations on the issue.

The commission had a couple of years ago banned the telecast, publication or broadcast of exit polls during polls till the final phase of voting but media houses approached the apex court after which the order was revoked.

The commission had asked the court to decide whether there should be a reasonable restriction in publication and dissemination of results of opinion polls and exit polls during certain specified periods during the election process.

The government had in October last decided to amend the Representation of the People Act, 1951, to curb publication of exit polls during elections till the conclusion of the final phase so that it does not “influence” voters. The government’s move to amend the RPA is seen as an effort to ensure polls, which are generally spread over several phases, are free and fair.

“No result of any opinion or exit poll conducted at any time shall be published, publicized or disseminated in any manner by print, electronic or any other media at any time during the period of 48 hours ending with the hour fixed for closing of poll in an electioin held in a single phase,” the EC said.

“In a multi-phased election and in the case of elections in different states announced simultaneously,” the EC barred dissemination of opinion and exit polls by the media “at any time during the period starting from 48 hours before the hour fixed for closing of poll in the first phase of the election and till the poll is concluded in all the phases in all states”, the guidelines said.

EC bans exit, opinion poll till voting comes to a close

By Sudha Raman

The Election Commission on Tuesday banned dissemination of results of opinion and exit polls during the 48-hour period till the polling ends in case of single-phase election. It also banned exit polls till the last lap in the event of multi-phase elections.

The EC’s move comes against the backdrop of the Supreme Court leaving it to the discretion of the commission to decide on laying down guidelines on opinion and exit polls till the government frames regulations on the issue.

The commission had a couple of years ago banned the telecast, publication or broadcast of exit polls during polls till the final phase of voting but media houses approached the apex court after which the order was revoked.

The commission had asked the court to decide whether there should be a reasonable restriction in publication and dissemination of results of opinion polls and exit polls during certain specified periods during the election process.

The government had in October last decided to amend the Representation of the People Act, 1951, to curb publication of exit polls during elections till the conclusion of the final phase so that it does not “influence” voters. The government’s move to amend the RPA is seen as an effort to ensure polls, which are generally spread over several phases, are free and fair.

“No result of any opinion or exit poll conducted at any time shall be published, publicized or disseminated in any manner by print, electronic or any other media at any time during the period of 48 hours ending with the hour fixed for closing of poll in an electioin held in a single phase,” the EC said.

“In a multi-phased election and in the case of elections in different states announced simultaneously,” the EC barred dissemination of opinion and exit polls by the media “at any time during the period starting from 48 hours before the hour fixed for closing of poll in the first phase of the election and till the poll is concluded in all the phases in all states”, the guidelines said.

Medchal Constituency Map

Medchal Constituency Map